2026 Pastel Society of New Mexico Presentation







Donald Hagerty, The Art and Life of Maynard Dixon, page 137: “Hambidge harbored reservations about the

modern tendency to regard design as instinctive or intuitive and initiated his theory, a mathematical system

of composition based on the relationship of the diagonal to the sides of a rectangle “


Dynamic Symmetry can be viewed as a tool. Its versatility may suggest design possibilities that the artist might not otherwise consider. A composer is not hampered by knowledge of musical theory. An artist should not be hampered by knowledge of composition theories







Dynamic Symmetry Diagram Construction:. 

1. Main Diagonals from corners to corners. 
2. Lines crossing the diagonals at 90 degree angles from top right and bottom right corners to the top and bottom edges forming an “X” on the right side.
3. Lines crossing the diagonals at 90 degree angles from the top left and bottom left corners to the top and bottom edges forming an “X” on the left side.
4. Polar lines (4) through the intersections of the main diagonals with their crossing lines (aka, “reciprocals”). 

Focal points can be selected from the four intersections of the main diagonals and their reciprocals. Note that they generally do NOT divide the canvas into thirds. The magic of this construction is that the X’s formed by the reciprocals are diagonals of (vertical) rectangles with the same proportion as the original rectangle (proven elsewhere, using geometric methods). You will see in this presentation remarks by many artists proclaiming the harmony of the subdivision of a rectangle into “self-similar” rectangles.


For a rectangle, the term, aspect ratio is used to describe its characteristic proportion:

aspect ratio =  the length divided by the width. 


Hence the aspect ratio of a 3 to 4 rectangle is 4/3 or 1.3333... where ... denotes continues indefinitely. The aspect ratio of any proportional rectangle proportional to the 3 to 4 is the same; eg, 9x12, 12x16, 18x24, 30x40. By the way we say that a 9x12 and a 12x9 have the same aspect ratio.

Other examples: the aspect ratio of an 8x10 is 10/8 - 5/4 =1.25, the same as the aspect ration of a 16x20.  

Recommendation: use an 8x10 study for a 16x20 since they have the same proportion.


Use this transparency (distributed as a transparency on acetate with 2 inch high diagrams) to match images in the sheet of 2 inch high photo images provided. Look through the transparency also at the screen, lining the appropriate "panel" up with the large painting image (if possible). Become very familiar with these dynamic symmetry diagrams. They will help the artist imprint the proportion in his/her muscle memory. Note how the main diagonals of different rectangles have different slants with the last (Root 5) rectangle at a considerably shallower slant. (The square diagram is a different from the others here as its diagonals cross each other at right angles; hence the reciprocals are the same as the main diagonals. For this reason the square has a different diagram: two side by side 2 to 1 rectangles). In this presentation, I will show you some alternatives to diagrams using combinations of dynamic symmetry diagrams.


The middle diagram indicates perhaps how the Fibonacci Series and the Golden Spiral Rectangle are related……Fibonacci series: 1,1,2,35,8,13,21,34,55,… Not all spirals are golden.  A spiral is said to be golden if the ratio of the lengths between whorls is a golden mean, approximately 1.618. Some spirals have equal distances (the Archimedean spiral). Greek artists and designers were very interested in spirals as seen in their columns. A full workshop would spend some time constructing spirals.



Lines can direct attention to a focal point, diagonal lines creating a sense of movement, or horizontal and vertical lines establishing balance and harmony. 

 








Halbert, 2016 Dynamic Symmetry:


2016: Santa Fe River Turbulence, I was conscious of utilizing a "golden spiral" with a focal point at the golden mean. Fortunately, I had chosen a golden ratio for the panel: 10 x 16 (or as close as I could get to the golden ratio irrational number).  I noticed that the rocks formed a kind of spiral, spiraling to that point and I took advantage of that. Comment by Jeff Legg, Judge: “I could live with this painting”.

2020: Blowin’ in the Wind: Remarks from the transcript of the judge, Lynn Boyer:
“Full of energy.. Engaging, vibrant, melodic. Swept around in it. Not just a painting of a tree. I feel the movement of the tree as the wind whips it around.
Unique painting.”
Tragically, Lynn passed away of a heart attack at a young age. The world is lessened by her absence.


Halbert, 2024 Dynamic Symmetry:

2024, Turbulent Lands, 15x25, near golden rectangle. Click on this extensive description of the painting: Anatomy of Turbulent Lands

2024, Ghost Ranch Cabin, 9x12. Note the pencil lines in this oil and graphite painting.




Halbert, 2025, 26 Dynamic Symmetry:

2025: Abiquiu Cliffs Abstract, Judge Qiang Huang’s comments: "This painting is unique. The asymmetric color shapes are on top of a symmetric geometric pattern, showing a mathematical beauty."

2026: Ghost Ranch Tapestry, Judge Steve Atkin’s comments: “I love everything about Karen's painting. When you first look at it, you might notice the way she applied the paint. Like tapestry, or like the aged rock face, it looks weathered by Sun & Wind. The color temperature shifts are gorgeous & subtle (just like in life,) and she has this pop of ultramarine blue sparkles to lead your eye along the rock face.

The trees are feathery and airy. The composition seems to follow the Fibonacci Spiral and golden ratio, which is always a solid foundation. “



An early pastel painting (2004) hanging in our alcove library, painted in a class by Keith Gunderson. Keith was my first classical realist instructor, the one who alerted me to how master painters used the golden spiral in paintings (as well as many other concepts). Keith currently teaches at the Woodstock School of Art. Included to show that I spent some time with pastel - and loved it but it doesn't love me.  I began to work with oils (with Keith) after this time while still living in Woodstock. I moved to Santa Fe around 2006.



Sketches by Higgins, Bellows, Bisttram, Parrish. Advocates of Dynamic Symmetry.

The “scaffolding” lines in these drawings are variations of lines used for the Dynamic Symmetry compositions.

Drawings by Bellows show his mastery of Dynamic Symmetry. Jay Hambidge included Bellows’ "Dynamic Plans” in his published works on Dynamic Symmetry. 

William Victor Higgins was known to check his design sometimes with a grid/armature. In an interview in 1932, Higgins stated:  “The modern painter builds his picture; he does not merely paint it. He has his superstructure, his foundation, just as an architect has for his buildings.”

Parrish frequently referred to the proportions used in Dynamic Symmetry.

We will revisit these artists later in the presentation.

I added the red dynamic symmetry lines to the Bisttram Kachina drawing to incite how close his lines were.



Sketches by Degas,  Jonson, Dixon, Nadler.

The “scaffolding” lines in these drawings are variations of lines used for compositions.

Adoration of the Magi, Da Vinci: Linear perspective line armature with vanishing point 

Dixon developed his own theory of composition. Historians stated that if he had known about Dynamic Symmetry he might have used it. Dixon did paint in New Mexico with DS advocates.

Jonson was known to use geometric principles as was Nadler.

I own the Nadler study in the second row and showed it to the audience. It's a vellum study painted in gouache. I should have included this image in the dynamic symmetry historic studies' slide since in fact if you look carefully at the image, you can see dynamic symmetry pencil lines (main diagonal with a crossing, right-angle reciprocal line). 


Byrne, Fryer, Halbert. See the article, The Science of Beauty by Bob Bahr





While Degas did not explicitly adopt Hambidge’s theory, his compositional choices — such as aligning figures along implied axes, balancing masses, and using repeating proportional units — align with the principles of dynamic symmetry. This is why art analysts often point to his paintings as examples of the system in practice,

Dynamic symmetry is a proportional system for creating balanced compositions, and artists like Degas have used its principles — even if unconsciously — to structure their works, resulting in compositions that feel both dynamic and harmonious.



The heads fit nicely inside the Dynamic Symmetry lines.. Lines frame the head and follow the arms, etc.. Note how the right edge of the table aligns with the right edge of the one of the Dynamic Symmetry Lines. The figures in the painting are not perfectly symmetric of course. But there is a sense of balance.


Sketch with Parrish’s lines. 


Chimayo is in a prominent position at the New Mexico Museum of Art. When I visited it; I was thrilled. I investigated a little and found that Bellows had attended a class on Dynamic Symmetry before he visited New Mexico and painted this. In fact, Bellows, became Hambidges’ star student. As a trained carpenter it was natural perhaps for Bellows to incorporate proportional guidelines. Robert Henri invited Bellows to Santa Fe in 2017.  Chimayo was painted during his stay. Please do go to the museum to see this Chimayo painting. 

The placard as read in 2013: “Not all of the East Coast artists working in New Mexico found the southwest an ideal place to paint. George Bellows was known for his images of prizefighters reflecting the antagonisms of urban life. In the summer of 1917, he followed Robert Henri’s advice and came to New Mexico. , 30.5x44

But in New Mexico Bellows found the expansive spaces, rural scenes, and intense light difficult to paint, as is evident in Chimayó . The acidy light and awkward green vegetation reveals [sic] an accomplished artist wrestling with new and unfamiliar subject matter. The painting of the horse in the foreground underscores the difficulty he had with the local scene,” 


What do you think?  The current placard is more complimentary.


AR 40/25=8/5 = 1.6, near the golden mean.  I found it intriguing that the compositions of these two paintings were similar, so I continue to use this as an example in the workshops and presentations.


I wanted to continue looking at O'Keeffe's paintings with Dynamic Symmetry in mind. There's no evidence that she used the system BUT she was living in Manhattan at the time when so many artists were discussing or using the theory.  Her sister, Ida,  (living and attending art classes with her for a while) did give evidence that she used dynamic symmetry (with a golden cut construction on the back of a painting).  tThe Dallas Museum held a retrospective on Ida's work, titled The Forgotten Sister. The show catalog has an excellent article on Dynamic Symmetry in Ida's Lighthouse Series (more about this in workshops).

I did not include this image in the actual presentation due to time constraints, but I found Georgia's use of a Root 5 proportion intriguing enough that I added golden spirals to the painting image. Note the square area intersection of the spirals. You will see this diagram later in the presentation.


The 3 to 4 proportion divides perfectly into two (vertical) 3 to 2 proportions with the dynamic symmetry diagrams seen here.  What do you think? 

The dynamic symmetry lines are quite visible. According to Art Historian, Traugott, How the West was One, NMMA., Bisttram used the principles of dynamic symmetry to structure works such as Kachina Series #4. Bisttram “, drew, rather than measured, the divisions to prevent the understructure from becoming overly mechanical. … The resulting drawing combines universal spirituality of the golden mean and dynamic symmetry with the culturally specific spirituality of the Pueblo kachinas.”. 

From the Peyton Wright Gallery: “His development into abstraction was strongly influenced by Native American geometric designs and symbolism.”

Bisttram lived in Taos from 1931 until his death in 1975. He was a life-long advocate of dynamic symmetry and a popular teacher of it.

Due to time constraints I did not mention that Bisttram co-founded the Transcendental Painting Group - to be studied much more in the future.

 
I've become fascinated with works by Harry Nadler. This painting clearly illustrated Nadler's knowledge of and use of a golden rectangle construction. He divided a square on the left side into two and drew the line from the midpoint on the bottom to the upper right of the square (my blue square). Then he used a compass to draw the arc down to the bottom edge. It can be shown that the rectangle constructed from this point up to the upper right is a golden rectangle. Measure if for yourself. You can see that the aspect ratio is approximately 1.618 (think 10x16.18) or in this case, the dimensions are: 24x40 and 40/24 = 10/6 = 1.66... an approximation to the golden mean.



Michele is known for her use of the Dynamic Symmetry Armature – an expanded one to include the Self-Similar Rectangles and Rebated Squares. Her Facebook posts frequently include steps where you can see pencil marks from the armature in the intermediate steps of her painting. Michele has been told by her followers that her compositions improved after she began using the Expanded Dynamic Symmetry Armature; she started winning even more awards.

She has a very informative article that I highly recommend, available through the Oil Painters of America:  https://www.oilpaintersofamerica.com/2022/03/dynamic-symmetry-and-how-i-incorporate-it-into-my-plein-air-and-studio-and-practice/

 

Doug Fryer has utilized variations of Dynamic Symmetry in his many workshops and University Classrooms. This painting and reference photo are from his video Painting with Intuition, available from Streamline Publishing.   Trailers are available through Google. Radical Division is a name I am giving for a construction of Root Rectangles inside a square.




The largest flower lies close to the intersection of a main diagonal with one of its reciprocals, a good position for a major focal point.  I like the way the lemons lie along this main diagonal, seemingly pointing to the main flower. Sarah related to me that she did not use dynamic symmetry in her design but it seems to me that the diagram captures her intent very nicely.



Natasha has a technical background and taught art for some years at NM Tech, so it's natural to me that her paintings work so well with dynamic symmetry. I have also found that her paintings use linear perspective perfectly (I used to teach it to undergraduate liberal arts' students in math classes). However, she told me that she simply eye's the scene as is. I've had fun constructing perspective lines with some of her more complicated buildings.  By the way, Natasha likes to use double-square format (aka, 1 to 2 or Root 4). But of course, she has many paintings in other formats.





Due to time constraints I did not include Abiquiu Afternoon in the presentation.

Paul likes asymmetric paintings as can be seen here. He does not use Dynamic Symmetry but I like the way his lines align with the dynamic symmetry diagram.

The square root of 5 is 2.236….  The dimensions of this painting are 14x30, 30/14 = 15/7 = 2 1/7 – 2.14… close enough to 2.236…. The border lines indicate that the diagram is not exact. It would be interesting to superimpose interlocking golden spirals but in fact I don't think this diagram would reveal anything new about the composition. (Try looking at the image with the Root 5 transparency handed out to the audience).


 The aspect ratio of this painting was familiar to me, 1.111.. or close to 1.18, a popular aspect ratio used by George Bellows (and made famous in Jay Hambidge's book). So I superimposed two vertical Root 5 dynamic symmetry diagrams side by side and then applied interlocking RED golden spirals as indicated in the diagram on the right.


“It is essential to remember that the shapes and movements of the subject relate to one another and to the picture plane, creating the divisions of the picture plane.”

Page 126. Division of the Picture Plane, Intuitive Composition, Albert Handell. I used this quote here since it still applies.  This statement supports the theory of dynamic symmetry. As indicated by the title of Albert's book, he approaches his compositions intuitively. But I find that his works align beautifully with the theory.  And recall again that Albert did write in 1985 in this book that "The most exciting older book I read recently is Dynamic Symmetry by Jay Hambidge."



Albert and I have given three workshops together over the past few years, with his part on Intuitive Composition and my part on Dynamic Symmetry of course. Watch for an announcement about a forthcoming workshop on Waterfalls, which might be offered this year, if scheduling allows: Karen's Workshop Page














In this Harry Nadler work, his construction of a golden rectangle is evident: constructing an arc from the upper right corner of a square down to the bottom edge (my red highlighted arc to emphasize this). (24x40 is close to a golden mean since 40/24 = 1.6).



I often use the golden mean caliper to check that some points of interest are at a golden mean proportion, approximately 38-62% ratio.



Upon further analysis of this painting, I realized that instead of measuring with a ruler as I did here, I could look for 1 to 2 rectangles and then figure out how he used the golden cut to mark off golden divisions. (Hint: to construct a golden cut, look for a diagonal of a 2 to 1 rectangle, construct a semicircle with the short edge as a radius, then construct a semicircle from the opposite end of the diagonal; its radius arc will mark off a golden rectangle on the edge/ In the case of the diagram the radius is 6.18).  Note that the measurements for the painting are not quite 10x16.18, but pretty close.)

His vertical lines align well with the verticals in the Dynamic Symmetry diagram.


As mentioned earlier in the presentation, I purchased this study. You can see Nadler's initials in the lower right. The study came from the owner of the Santa Fe Gallery, https://farahnheight.com

I've begun to do some pastel studies on Vellum as an experiment. Soft pencil and the hard Nu-pastels seem to adhere nicely to the vellum. Expect to see more of these studies in the future.




Afterword

Photo of me at the presentation:


Right before the presentation, I visited the Albuquerque Museum exhibition on New Mexico Art just across the hall from the auditorium and found three paintings immediately by artists referenced in this talk: Emil Bisttram, Harry Nadler and William Victor Higgins. I mentioned this to the audience and encouraged them to visit the exhibit and look at the following three paintings with the viewer distributed to the audience (and seen in one of the earlier slides in this presentation: download it and print it on acetate to create your own viewer; laminating it with a 10 mil pouch on a thermo laminator would give you a better result. Or download the images and then you can just draw diagrams on the images after printing them). 
Emil Bisttram, Pueblo Girl-Juanita, 1934, oil

I don't want to leave Bisttram without again referring to the Transcendental Painting Group which he co-founded.

A Transcendental Painting image from a book in my library:
Emil Bisttram, Atonement, 1965, 52x36, oil


Harry Nadler, Magic Square I, 1983, oil, Albuquerque Museum.

I found another painting on the museum website that is not on view. I will be analyzing this one as I do a few others in the presentation. And this is acrylic and pastel on paper. You can try analyzing it too:
Harry Nadler, Untitled II. 12 1/8 x 26 1/8, 1985, acrylic and pastel on paper.

This is similar to the painting, Gateways. It looks like he considered this a study for a much larger painting since his painting similar to this one is larger. I could have used this an an example since it has a spiral along with two half circles.


Victor William Higgins, Albuquerque Museum, Aspect Ratio 1.14..

I also saw three paintings by Raymond Jonson (see the historic sketch page #2), which I might add later.












 

Popular posts from this blog

Anatomy of a Seurat Painting and Santa Fe River Turbulence by Halbert

Snapseed App for the iPhone- How to add a grid to your painting or photo

Design Armature Examples applied to the Santa Fe River Turbulence, a Golden Rectangle Painting