Comparison of Harmonic and Dynamic Symmetry Armatures

http://www.the-art-of-composition.com/blog/the-relationship-between-dynamic-symmetry-and-the-harmonic-armature James Cowman

"For those who have taken the time to investigate both design systems, the harmonic armature and root rectangles, the artist may wonder what the difference is between them since they both provide harmonic divisions.
In my opinion, I find using the 14 line armature of the rectangle easier to learn when it comes to analyzing art as well as applying it to a composition. For example, you can purchase any size canvas you want at your local art store and draw a 14 line armature to create a successful composition.

​The other significant difference between both design systems is that Dynamic Symmetry allows the artist to break down the mother rectangle into smaller versions of the original rectangle. The painting below by Conor Walton demonstrates the relationship between the 14 line armature and the root four (2) Dynamic Symmetry rectangle (2:1 ratio)."

My Analysis

Assumption: the points of intersection of any diagonals, horizontals and verticals are harmonic points of division. Given a as the width of the canvas and b as the height.  Then the distance from the intersection point to one of the following is the harmonic mean of a and b or some combination of a and b (sometimes only one): edge or corner. A corollary is that the distance between two intersections would be harmonic.
We denote a harmonic division as the intersection of any diagonal (not necessarily major) and another one or a vertical or horizontal.  Note that if a horizontal or a vertical intersects at this point then it might be even 'more harmonic'. However, an intersection of a horizontal with a vertical without a diagonal passing through it is not considered 'harmonic'.
We will call the 4 main horizontal intersection points the "sweet spots". Note that in the harmonic armature these four sweet spots obey the rule of thirds (proof given elsewhere in this blog).

Dynamic Symmetry or Harmonic Grid:

  • symmetric horizontally and vertically.  This can lead to boring compositions; the artist is required to avoid mirror image sections.

The Dynamic Symmetry Grid: 



  • fewer number of harmonic divisions
  • But additional harmonic divisions can be found when  break down an area of interest further within a smaller rectangular area
  • Canvases with wider proportions have more empty space in the middle
  • The crossing lines, also called reciprocals, perpendicular to the main diagonals add dynamism to the composition.

Harmonic Armature Grid:

  • Many diagonal lines for directing the eye (dashed lines).
  • Extension of Rule of Thirds (left knee is at a ROT point)

Combined Grids (as a possibility and to illustrate the differences/similarities):



  • many harmonic divisions (perhaps it is too hard to keep track of the divisions.)
  • requires practice with its use since there are so many possibilities for identifying focal points



Popular posts from this blog

Color Wheel Revisited

Image
We will be using the triadic color wheel from the Color Wheel Company to illustrate color relationships. a good resource is the book, Color is Everything, by Dan Bartges, a book with thorough descriptions of this tool (I will have it in the workshop for you to peruse).  Triadic Color Wheel from the Color Wheel Company: Study of the Triadic Color Wheel. The color wheel provides 12 hues around the circle on each side  On the one side we can see the effects of mixing red, yellow and blue and white and black with each of the 12 hues by rotating the wheel. This side also has a value scale that can be matched up with each of the hues to identify the value of each hue. The second side shows the tint, tone and shade for each of the hues. Directions are provided for determining analogous colors, complementaries , split complements, triads and tetrads. We will be discussing these at length. For a preliminary website link with definitions see:  http://www.tigercolor.com/col
Read more

(extra) Color Palette Examples

Image
==================================== Limited palette of Don Finkeldei: www.finkeldeistudio.com. I have studied with Don and used his method extensively. He has many articles on the topic that are well worth reading and re-reading. His color charts, are quite useful and found in a new article on the website. His color palette consists of the Utrecht Artist Oils: cadmium yellow light, cadmium red light, ultramarine blue plus white, as well as alizarin crimson and viridian for transparent darks and sometimes the convenience color, cadmium orange.  He creates a few values of greys from a dark formed by the yellow, red and blue to be used in the mixing.  He also uses his AC/V transparent dark for accents. He pre-mixes his colors on the palette. ==================================== String Palette: I would like to include some material here on the palette of strings based on the Munsell theory, that formed my very first palette for oil painting. My instructor was the artist, Kei
Read more

(extra) Color Mixing on the web with online Apps with RGB and CMYK

Image
May begin color mixing by studying color pickers provided by on-line tools. These are based on the RGB color wheel for web development, with its additive nature.   So first, an explanation of the RGB colors on the color wheel. We will see the representation of the R, G, B hues as 'hexadecimal'; e.g., red is #FF0000, where the FF masks the red perfectly and 00 masks the green and blue perfectly, but you will notice that the third hue in these tertiaries are masked with 7F. Binary numbers are 0's and 1's; 7 = 0111 in binary; F = 1111 in binary, so we see 0, 7 and F here. White would be FFFFF a perfect mix of R, G and B, while Black is 000000, a complete absence of an R, G or B. Yellow, magenta and cyan are complements of blue, green and red in this scheme.  In fact the hexadecimal notation for these complements has '1's in place of '0' and vice versa for the primaries and secondaries.  The tertiaries are aligned somewhat differently., with 7F m
Read more